Thomson's Violinist Analogy

That is a feature of Gordon's disceptationation against abortion: "To conceive and then abort matchless's child is to trance conception into a deadly trap for the child: it is to found her up in a vulnerable position that is just ab off certain to lead to her death" (Gordon). Gordon glosses over the notion that that the fetus may be a deadly trap for a mother, which is analogous to the kidnap victim's guaranteed kidney failure and death because of being secure to the violinist. The fetus, in that view has an unmediated right to be in the womb, whatever the cost to the woman in the case--and, it appears, whether the pregnancy was the return of rape or consensual sex. As Gordon puts it: "The problem in rape is whether the victimization of one person should permit the victimization of someone else." By that logic the fact of pregnancy has the feeling of suppressing the rights and options of the pregnant person. The only value that this person has is as a repository for a pregnancy; all other value slip away. Hirschmann (49-50) exposes that line of thought by arguing that mandating a woman to complete unwanted pregnancy is the equivalent of lay her in a condition of involuntary servitude.

Thomson develops the view that lesson entitlement to choose an abortion has limits, chiefly where pargonnts have made a conscious effort to conceive. But she sights

cse/pubs/2009/reports/preliminary_report_fy2008/>.

Gordon, Doris. "Abortion and Thomson's Violinist: Unplugging a Bad Analogy: Comments on Why the Prenatal Child Has the Right Under individual(a) Liberty to Be in the Mother's Womb." Libertarians for Life, 1991, 1993. The weight of evidence is that the argument lamenting the fate of the poor fellows who are cut out of the personhood loop is very close to nonsense, if real-world experience is any guide. take down with the enforcement of child support mandates. In FY 2008, there was more than $31 billion in current support due. Of that, some $19 billion (62% of the total) was collected and distri scarcelyed, "an increase of 3.

3 persona points over the percentage of current support collected and distributed in FY 2007" (OCSE). Next interpret behavior of public officials who have made a bulge out of creating regulations meant to intervene between a woman's decision to abort and murder of the decision. As Justice John Paul Stevens noted in his opinion in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which upheld a 24-hour hold period regulation for any woman requesting an abortion, "there is no evidence that the mandated delay benefits women . . . . The mandatory delay thus appears to liberalisation on outmoded and unacceptable assumptions about the decision-making capacity of women" (Lemieux; idiom added). Assumptions about women's psychoemotional condition that are embedded into law are evidence of the presumptive devaluation not just of women's autonomy but of their status as sentient beings, of, so to speak, their personhood. Irrespective of how one feels about abortion, that discrepancy in the standing of men and women forwards the law, hence their access to the full range of social goods, is worth noting.

Ordercustompaper.com is a professional essay writing service at which you can buy essays on any topics and disciplines! All custom essays are written by professional writers!